In a culture that prizes productivity and performance, perfectionism can seem like a virtue. We praise people for their “high standards” and “drive to succeed.” Some of us even wear the label of “perfectionist” like a badge of honor.

But as pastoral counselor Rachael Isaac of the Pastoral Solutions Institute warns, perfectionism isn’t a superpower. It’s a trap, one that leads to stress, restlessness, and strained relationships with others…even God.

“Perfectionism can manifest in a variety of different ways and different areas of our life,” Isaac explains. “But at the bottom, it’s about feeling like we might not be good enough, and that we need to work really hard to control both how we present to the world and our environment so that things are okay.”

The Hidden Ways Perfectionism Shows Up

The word “perfectionist” might conjure up the image of someone who insists everything has to be “just so.”

But often, Isaac says, it takes other forms: manifesting as the need to do everything yourself, for instance, or filtering what you say to make sure you say things the “right” way. Even procrastination can be a form of perfectionism, she says—a stress response to the fear of doing something imperfectly.

At its core, perfectionism is about comparison and fear. We compare ourselves to others, afraid that if we don’t measure up, we’ll be judged or rejected. Sometimes, that comparison flips, and we hold others to the impossible standards we set for ourselves, fueling criticism and resentment. Regardless of how it presents, the underlying dynamic remains the same: an attempt to manage deep-seated insecurity through external control.

That’s not the way God wants us to live, Isaac says. God wants us to know, deep in our bones, that our worth comes not from what we do, but from who we are as children of God.

At the deepest level, then, overcoming perfectionism is about learning to live from a place of deep, God-given confidence—the kind that frees us to love, serve, and rest without fear.

Breaking Free from Perfectionism: Three Strategies

In her work helping people develop this God-given confidence, Isaac has come up with a suite of strategies for addressing perfectionism. Here are three you can try on your own today:

1. Exchange “What-If” Questions for “Even-If” Statements

Perfectionism fuels anxiety with endless “what if” questions: What if my house isn’t clean enough when guests arrive? What if I make a mistake during my presentation? What if my spouse doesn’t do the laundry the way I do it?

These what-if questions leave open a whole range of possible worst case scenarios, Isaac says; this uncertainty can leave us feeling like we’ve lost control. We try to resolve that uncertainty by answering the question, usually focusing on the worst-case scenario.

To break that cycle, Isaac recommends swapping “what if” questions for “even if” statements, completing those sentences with realistic, hopeful outcomes:

• Even if my house isn’t completely clean, we’ll still have a good time together.
• Even if I stumble during my presentation, people will still understand my message.
• Even if my spouse ‘messes up’ the laundry, it’s still getting done
• .—and the important thing is that we’re working together as a team.

“As soon as I make an ‘even if’ statement, I can be more solution-focused and find that peace and control—even if everything’s not perfect,” Isaac says.

2. Set Realistic Expectations

Perfectionists often set impossible expectations for themselves and others.

Isaac gives the example of someone who is anxious to get the house cleaned up before dinner guests arrive. Someone grounded in their God-given identity might pick up the main spaces and set out flowers to be hospitable to their guests.

But the person trapped in a perfectionist mindset takes that impulse to an extreme, trying to clean the whole house—and nagging everyone else to pitch in with that Herculean task.

That is not a helpful or realistic expectation, Isaac points out.

A better approach is to ask: What’s truly necessary? Adjust your expectations for yourself and others accordingly, resting in the knowledge that whatever your guests may think, your identity comes from God, not the state of your house.

3. Recognize the Good You Already Do

Perfectionism tempts us to dismiss the moments that really matter—the everyday acts of love, service, and connection that reflect our God-given strengths. To combat perfectionism, Isaac recommends taking time to reflect on those moments.

For example, let’s say you’re trying to tick off items on your to-do list when your kid starts melting down. You set aside your agenda, sitting down on the floor to hold and comfort them.

Someone trapped in a perfectionist mindset might overlook this action because it’s not “productive.”

“But recognizing how good that moment was…and that I had strengths in that moment to be present, patient, compassionate—that really shifts the mindset from performance to recognizing my God-given strengths,” Isaac says.

And when we learn to see the good in ourselves, we’re freer to see—and celebrate—the good in others, too.

The Gift of Living in Freedom

Isaac has seen this shift transform people’s lives. She shares the story of a client who struggled to ask her husband for help. Perfectionism made her feel that if she wasn’t doing everything herself, she was failing. But as she practiced communicating her needs, the dynamic in their marriage changed.

“She was able to recognize that having it all on her wasn’t what defined her worth or her success,” Isaac says. “She could really be effective—maybe even more so—when she communicated her needs and worked together with her husband.”

The journey out of perfectionism is really a journey into freedom.

“You’re moving from a place of constant pressure to a place of greater peace,” Isaac says. “It impacts your relationship with yourself, with others, and with God. You begin to realize you don’t have to earn your worth—you’re already enough.”

For more one-on-one help with perfectionism and confidence, reach out to Rachael Isaac or another pastoral counselor at CatholicCounselors.com.

Or join Rachael Isaac on Thursday July 31st at 8pm EST for a power-packed, one hour, live webinar: Empowered–Overcoming Perfectionism and Achieving Your Goals