
For decades, Jill has been married to a husband who is unfaithful, alcoholic, and doesn’t treat her with respect. Concerned about the impact of their marital woes on her young adult son, she has worked to hold the relationship together by seeking counseling and spiritual direction on her own.
When she asks her husband to join her in marriage counseling, he flatly refuses, saying it won’t work and he doesn’t need it.
“And then basically everything gets turned back on me,” Jill told Dr. Greg and Lisa Popcak when she called into their Even More To Life Podcast. He blames their relationship problems on her: “You know, if you had lost weight and if you weren’t religious…” etc.
Her question for the Popcaks: What do I do next?
“What you’ve got here is a perfect example of how we can’t hold a relationship all together on our own,” Dr. Popcak told her.
Counterintuitively, his advice didn’t involve doing more, but doing less: letting the relationship fall apart so that it might actually be repaired.
You Can’t Hold a Broken Vase Together
Dr. Popcak offered Jill a vivid metaphor for her situation: Imagine trying to hold together a broken vase by wrapping your hands and body around it.
“If you even move a finger, the whole thing is just going to fall apart,” he said. “But you’re walking around all wrapped around this shattered vase, holding it all together on your own and saying, look how I’m holding the vase together. And I guess the question you have to ask yourself is, are you?”
By assuming sole responsibility for repairing the relationship, Jill was effectively sheltering her husband from reality.
“He doesn’t want to seek counseling because, honestly, the relationship works for him,” Dr. Greg explained. “He’s getting what he wants out of the relationship, because you’re holding it together enough to make him happy.”
The Communion We’re Made For
The impulse to hold the relationship together on your own is understandable—and, in fact, rooted in a holy impulse. As St. John Paul II explored in his Theology of the Body, we were created for mutual, self-giving communion. Prior to the Fall, humanity lived in genuine transparency, receiving one another’s differences as gifts. Relationship estrangement echoes that primordial rupture.
“The longing you feel to reconnect, that ache that says this isn’t how it’s supposed to be—that isn’t weakness,” Lisa Popcak said. “That’s God’s design for communion, working exactly the way it was meant to.”
The impulse to repair and restore the relationship is good, but a one-sided martyrdom that confuses peace-keeping with peacemaking isn’t the way to do it, the Popcaks said.
Authentic Christian unity is inherently Trinitarian: mutual, reciprocal, and grounded in truth.
“We can’t make relationships work all on our own, and God is not asking us to do that,” Dr. Popcak emphasized.
To Begin Repairing a Relationship, First Let Go
Before a broken relationship can be restored, you first need to stop trying to hold it together on your own, thereby exposing the reality of its brokenness.
Dr. Popcak urged Jill to work with her counselor to ask what it would look like, practically speaking, to “stop trying to hold all the pieces of that vase together, so that you and he and God and others could see how broken it really is.”
Only then, he said, would it be possible to figure out, together, what needs to happen to put the relationship back together in a healthy, authentic way.
God Has a Better Plan
Sometimes that rebuilding is possible and sometimes it isn’t on this side of heaven, Dr. Popcak said. The possibility that the relationship is unrepairable can be scary.
“I do believe that God has a plan for this,” he told Jill. But in order for that plan to unfold, we need to give God room to heal what is broken.
For support in healing a broken relationship, reach out to a pastoral counselor at CatholicCounselors.com, and see Dr. Popcak’s book God Help Me! These People Are Driving Me Nuts! for more on making peace with difficult people.










