Tired of Holding Your Relationship Together by Yourself? Try Letting Go

For decades, Jill has been married to a husband who is unfaithful, alcoholic, and doesn’t treat her with respect. Concerned about the impact of their marital woes on her young adult son, she has worked to hold the relationship together by seeking counseling and spiritual direction on her own.

When she asks her husband to join her in marriage counseling, he flatly refuses, saying it won’t work and he doesn’t need it.

“And then basically everything gets turned back on me,” Jill told Dr. Greg and Lisa Popcak when she called into their Even More To Life Podcast. He blames their relationship problems on her: “You know, if you had lost weight and if you weren’t religious…” etc.

Her question for the Popcaks: What do I do next?

“What you’ve got here is a perfect example of how we can’t hold a relationship all together on our own,” Dr. Popcak told her.

Counterintuitively, his advice didn’t involve doing more, but doing less: letting the relationship fall apart so that it might actually be repaired.

You Can’t Hold a Broken Vase Together

Dr. Popcak offered Jill a vivid metaphor for her situation: Imagine trying to hold together a broken vase by wrapping your hands and body around it.

“If you even move a finger, the whole thing is just going to fall apart,” he said. “But you’re walking around all wrapped around this shattered vase, holding it all together on your own and saying, look how I’m holding the vase together. And I guess the question you have to ask yourself is, are you?”

By assuming sole responsibility for repairing the relationship, Jill was effectively sheltering her husband from reality.

“He doesn’t want to seek counseling because, honestly, the relationship works for him,” Dr. Greg explained. “He’s getting what he wants out of the relationship, because you’re holding it together enough to make him happy.”

The Communion We’re Made For

The impulse to hold the relationship together on your own is understandable—and, in fact, rooted in a holy impulse. As St. John Paul II explored in his Theology of the Body, we were created for mutual, self-giving communion. Prior to the Fall, humanity lived in genuine transparency, receiving one another’s differences as gifts. Relationship estrangement echoes that primordial rupture.

“The longing you feel to reconnect, that ache that says this isn’t how it’s supposed to be—that isn’t weakness,” Lisa Popcak said. “That’s God’s design for communion, working exactly the way it was meant to.”

The impulse to repair and restore the relationship is good, but a one-sided martyrdom that confuses peace-keeping with peacemaking isn’t the way to do it, the Popcaks said.

Authentic Christian unity is inherently Trinitarian: mutual, reciprocal, and grounded in truth.

“We can’t make relationships work all on our own, and God is not asking us to do that,” Dr. Popcak emphasized.

To Begin Repairing a Relationship, First Let Go

Before a broken relationship can be restored, you first need to stop trying to hold it together on your own, thereby exposing the reality of its brokenness.

Dr. Popcak urged Jill to work with her counselor to ask what it would look like, practically speaking, to “stop trying to hold all the pieces of that vase together, so that you and he and God and others could see how broken it really is.”

Only then, he said, would it be possible to figure out, together, what needs to happen to put the relationship back together in a healthy, authentic way.

God Has a Better Plan

Sometimes that rebuilding is possible and sometimes it isn’t on this side of heaven, Dr. Popcak said. The possibility that the relationship is unrepairable can be scary.

“I do believe that God has a plan for this,” he told Jill. But in order for that plan to unfold, we need to give God room to heal what is broken.

For support in healing a broken relationship, reach out to a pastoral counselor at CatholicCounselors.com, and see Dr. Popcak’s book God Help Me! These People Are Driving Me Nuts! for more on making peace with difficult people.

For a Happier Marriage, Meet One Another’s Needs with Generous Curiosity. Here’s How.

Have you and your spouse ever gotten into a testy tug of war over conflicting wants and needs? If you’re married, odds are the answer is yes, because wherever there are two or more people, there are going to be differences.

The good news is, those differences make relationships interesting—and they don’t have to strain the relationship, as hosts Dr. Greg and Lisa Popcak explained on a recent episode of the CatholicHŌM podcast. In fact, there is a way to handle these minor conflicts that strengthens the relationship.

A Craft Fair Weekend Gone Bad

Imagine your spouse or friend asks you to do something you’d actively avoid, something nowhere on your personal agenda. All too often, the Popcaks said, people handle those situations by trying to “parent” the other person. The temptation, in their words, is “to try to convince the other person that they shouldn’t need what they need.” Or, sometimes, people resort to bartering.

That’s what happened to one couple the Popcaks knew. The wife loved quilting, while the husband could not have cared less about it. Once, the wife wanted to attend a distant Amish craft fair, and she wanted her husband to come along so she could spend time with him while enjoying the beautiful artistry of Amish quilts. To convince him to come, she offered a deal: they would look at quilts during the day, and then the two of them would have a romantic evening together.

Her husband agreed to go along…but spent the whole day rolling his eyes and groaning about the quilts. Not surprisingly, his wife wasn’t exactly in a romantic mood that evening, leaving the husband feeling their “deal” had been broken.

Practicing Generous Curiosity about Your Spouse’s Needs

So, what’s the better approach? The Popcaks point to a practice from the Liturgy of Domestic Church Life: prompt, generous, consistent, and cheerful attention to one another’s needs.

In practice, this means that when someone in your family (in this case, a spouse) expresses a need, instead of reacting negatively because that person’s need calls us out of our comfort zone, we choose to respond with generous curiosity. In this more open stance, we try to figure out what the person really needs and how that need might be met in a way that works out best for everyone.

It’s easy to imagine the response of the husband at the craft fair: “Well, no one needs to go to a craft fair.” But that stingy response assumes that needs only cover the basics necessary for survival: food, shelter, safety, and so on.

“And that’s not true at all,” Dr. Popcak said. “From a biological standpoint, a need is anything that helps an organism thrive, right? So a need is whatever helps you thrive.” And as Saint Irenaeus said, “the glory of God is man fully alive.” God doesn’t want us to just survive; he wants us to thrive.

This broader definition of needs doesn’t endorse an “anything goes” policy, however. Consider a wife who announces a girls’ wine weekend and hands her husband the kids, or a husband who disappears for eight to ten hours every Saturday of the summer to golf. Each may have a real need for a break and a chance to recharge, but that doesn’t give them license to impose the specifics of how and when that need for a break gets met.

As Dr. Popcak put it, “It’s not what we want that makes us selfish… It’s being inflexible about the how and the when.”

Three Steps for Meeting Each Other’s Needs with Generosity and Cheer

1. Name the need behind the request.

Before you announce a plan or push back on one, ask what the plan is for. The Popcaks suggest asking yourself, “Why do I want to do it? What would doing that do for me?” The answer is the real need at the bottom of what you want to do. A girls’ wine weekend may really be about a break and a chance to recharge, and a craft fair may be about enjoying beautiful things with someone you love. When your spouse is the one asking, you can ask the same questions of them.

2. Put both sets of needs on the table.

A request often raises legitimate concerns for the other spouse. A wife who wants a weekend away leaves her husband home with the kids; he, in turn, has a need for a plan that keeps the weekend from turning into chaos. When each spouse generously wishes to meet the real needs of the other, negotiating needs isn’t a winner-take-all game; it’s what Pope St. John Paul II called mutual self-donation.

3. Respond cheerfully

The “cheerful” part of your response isn’t about faking jollity or forcing smiles, the Popcaks said. Rather, it’s about overcoming that inner groan that you might feel when your spouse asks you for something that you’re not into. In place of that groan, practice curiosity about your spouse’s need and how best to meet it. And trust the process: When both spouses honor each other’s needs and stay flexible about how and when, there is less to groan about, because each knows their own concerns will be heard.

What the Craft Fair Could Have Looked Like

In our opening story, the husband’s curiosity about the real need behind his wife’s desire for him to attend the craft fair might have opened up other options. Or, understanding the real need behind his wife’s request might have helped him join her with a more positive and supportive attitude.

The wife could have started with the need, too. Had she told her husband that she wanted to enjoy beautiful things with him, they might have planned a day that included some quilts and some of the things he likes—plus a pleasant, romantic evening in the bargain.

No couple gets this right every time. The Popcaks call it a spiritual exercise to practice over and over again, since “we’re going to keep coming up with new needs, and that’s okay.” Each new need is another chance to leave behind our own comfort zones for the sake of love.

If you and your spouse keep running into the same standoffs, reach out to a pastoral counselor at CatholicCounselors.com. For more on building a marriage that lasts, see the Popcaks’ book, For Better…FOREVER! A Catholic Guide to Lifelong Marriage.

Teach Your Kids How to Handle Big Emotions the Catholic Way

If you have kids, whether they’re toddlers or teens, you’re living with people whose emotions sometimes get away from them. And when that happens, guess who gets to wrangle the fallout?

Many parents use one of two strategies to handle those flare-ups. There’s the hands-off approach that lets kids “vent.” And then there’s the approach that’s all about “shutting it down.” Often, the direction we take is shaped by what happened in our own homes when we got loud, tearful, or angry.

But as hosts Dr. Greg Popcak and Lisa Popcak explained on a recent episode of the CatholicHŌM podcast, there’s a third, better way.

Unlike the “shut-it-down” or “let them vent” approaches, this approach draws on Catholic teaching about emotions to help coach kids in the skills they need to handle their emotions appropriately.

Harnessing the “Passions”

Drawing on St. Thomas Aquinas and St. Pope John Paul II, the Church teaches that our emotions are given to us by God in order to draw us to himself. Our emotions (or “passions,” as Aquinas and other theologians called them) are therefore fundamentally good. Thanks to original sin, though, the way we handle and express those emotions is often distorted and disordered.

The best thing we can do with our passions, then, is to bring them to God, asking him to teach us how to respond to them in ways that are healthy and holy, enabling us to become everything God created us to be. If we are angry, for example, we can take that anger to God and ask him to help us harness that anger to achieve something good. Similarly, if we are sad or disappointed, we can ask the Holy Spirit to help us explore how those emotions are calling us to holiness in a particular situation.

This basically positive view of our emotions is the starting point for the approach the Popcaks advocate.

“For the Catholic parent, the question isn’t do we let our children just vent all over the place or do we shut down their emotions,” Dr. Popcak said. “It’s, ‘How do we teach our children to . . . express those passions in ways that work for their good, the good of others, and really build a kingdom?’ And that’s obviously a little more complicated process than either just shutting it down or letting them vent.”

Five Steps for Helping Your Kids Manage Their Emotions

The process of coaching your kids how to handle big emotions has five basic steps, the Popcaks say. Here’s what to do.

1. Empathize

“We don’t have to permit the behavior, but we can empathize with the emotion,” Dr. Popcak said.

We all know how wonderful it is when somebody empathizes with us when we feel angry or sad; we want to begin by doing the same thing for our kids.

“My first step here is to say, I really see how angry you are or how sad you are or how frightened you are, whatever that emotion is: ‘I really get that,’” Lisa Popcak explained, “so our children know that they’re being seen and heard.”

2. Help your child calm down

Even as your kids are hopefully reassured by your empathizing with their emotions, empathy isn’t enough to help them figure out how to handle those emotions. Lisa Popcak described the thought process a child might go through like this: “Okay, thank you. I’m glad I’m heard. I’m glad I’m seen. I’m glad I’m loved, even though I’m feeling this particular thing. But now what do I do with this? Teach me. Disciple me. Help me to know what I can do with all this, because it’s a little scary to feel this way.”

This step is all about coaching your child to shift from “reactivity” to “receptivity,” terms that St. John Paul II used in his Theology of the Body lectures. As Dr. Popcak explained, reactivity means instinctively acting on our impulses and feelings, so that our emotions end up in charge. Receptivity means pausing long enough to bring the feeling to God and ask what he wants us to do with it. That pause lets us settle down and think clearly.

“So, receptivity is the space that I create between my emotional reaction and my physical response to that emotional reaction,” Dr. Popcak said. “And the more space I have between those two things, the more I’m able to really think and problem solve as opposed to just reacting. That receptivity is how we encounter God speaking to us through our feelings and telling us what he wants us to do with them.”

With a child under six, this step usually means holding him close and helping him breathe until his body settles.

“You’re downloading your (slower) heart rate and respiration and calmer thoughts into their bodies by holding them close,” Lisa Popcak explained. At the same time, you continue to empathize with them, basically talking them down.

Older children who have developed self-talk (the narrative conversation we have with ourselves in our minds) may need some space to calm down on their own—especially if they are angry at you.

3. Pray and discern.

Now, pray with your child. The prayer should be very simple and direct: “You know, Lord, my child is so upset about this chore situation. Help us to figure out what you want us to do with this now.” Here, you are inviting the Holy Spirit into the situation to help both of you figure out what’s going on and what needs to happen.

Then look for the message underneath the emotion: “What is the child trying to communicate through that feeling?” Dr. Popcak asks. “What is the intention behind that impulse, that feeling?” The answer to that question is the problem that needs to be solved in the next step.

Let’s say that your child really doesn’t want to pick up their bedroom floor. You might initially think the answer is obvious: he’s trying to communicate that he doesn’t want to pick up the room!

Don’t be satisfied with that initial, superficial answer. Dig deeper. Fear might be the culprit: if he spends 10 minutes picking up the bedroom, he won’t get to do something else he wants to do. Or the mess might seem overwhelmingly impossible; younger children often have difficulty breaking a large task down into simpler parts.

4. Solve the real problem.

Once you know the intention behind your child’s big emotions, you can look for a healthy or virtuous way to meet the need behind it: “So, you were saying you were fighting me on doing the chore because you were afraid you wouldn’t be able to do this other thing,” Dr. Popcak said by way of example. “Well, let’s make a plan for doing that after the chore.”

5. Repair the relationship.

If feelings were expressed badly, with yelling, name-calling, or hitting, something needs to be mended. Dr. Popcak says the child needs to show that she is sorry, that she loves the person she hurt, and that she can be counted on. For smaller offenses, a sincere apology or a hug may be enough. For bigger ones, she might volunteer to do a chore for her sibling or perform another act of service.

It’s critical that the act of repair has a clear relationship to the offense, Lisa Popcak said: “It’s not an assignment. It’s organic to what needs to happen to rebuild that trust and that relationship again.”

Calm Parent, Calm Kid

As Lisa Popcak likes to point out, it is important to come into this process with your own sense of calm. All too often, our kids’ outbursts trigger our own emotional flooding. We react to our own heightened emotions by trying to impose control externally before we’ve harnessed those emotions to a good end. Prayer and lots of practice (and some grace for not being perfect!) help make this whole process a more organic habit.

Children who grow up with this approach learn that no feeling is too big for God or for their parents. They discover that they can be understood, helped, and forgiven, and that even their hardest emotions can point toward something good. Parents get to practice the same things themselves: pausing, praying, and listening for what God wants them to do with whatever they are feeling.

The Popcaks walk through all five steps in more detail in episode 110 of the CatholicHŌM podcast. If you’re wondering how the framework applies to a particular problem in your family, bring your questions to the coaching section of the CatholicHŌM app or reach out to a pastoral counselor at CatholicCounselors.com.

Don’t Settle for a Small Life; Practice Magnanimity Instead

The 2022 film Father Stu tells the true story of Stuart Long’s improbable journey to becoming a Catholic priest. After a hard childhood, he struggles with alcoholism as he restlessly pursues greatness, first as a boxer, then as an aspiring actor. He accepts baptism in the Catholic Church to win the heart of the woman he loves, but remains skeptical of God’s goodness.

After a near-death experience, he begins pursuing a deeper relationship with God. The journey unsettles him, though. While receiving confession one day, he complains that God is “[messing] with” him. “Another term for that,” says his beleaguered confessor, “is grace, God’s grace. It appears you are the recipient.”

For all of Stu’s shortcomings, he didn’t settle for a small life, but instead pursued greatness—even if he initially did so in the wrong places.

Later, that drive toward greatness would be refined into magnanimity, the virtue that propels us toward “greatness of soul.” And as Dr. Greg Popcak and Lisa Popcak explained on a recent episode of their radio show More2Life, magnanimity is the virtue that keeps us from settling for less than what God wants for us.

Why We Settle

Few of us would claim to have an all-around “great” life, and most of us can identify at least one part of our life that feels—well, not so great: a marriage that has gone flat, a job that stopped meaning much, a grown child you worry about, an aspiration that has gone unfulfilled.

As Christians, though, what matters is what we do next: Do we settle for the way things are, or do we make the changes that will lead to our best life?

All too often, the Popcaks say, we settle for the status quo out of fear or a lack of imagination or simply because it seems like the easier path.

“God calls us to live lives that reflect the greatness of God’s grace,” Lisa Popcak said. “And it can actually be sinful to live a small life rooted in a lack of courage, or small mindedness, or the idea that ‘that’s just the way it is.’ God wants more for us than we can even begin to want for ourselves.”

Sometimes, too, people mistakenly dress up their inclination to settle for the status quo as an act of humility. But neither humility nor self-denial are about accepting less than what God wants for us.

“Being humble doesn’t mean leading a powerless, limited, unfulfilling life of settling,” Dr. Greg said. “It means acknowledging that I don’t have the first clue how to live an abundant life…but simultaneously professing that with God’s grace, it will be done.”

Magnanimity: Pursuing Greatness

The restlessness that Stuart Long felt—and tried to satisfy in so many ways—comes from our God-given dignity.

“God built a longing into all of us, a longing for a love that doesn’t fail, for relationships that fulfill us, for a life that shows off God’s grace,” Lisa Popcak said. “That restlessness you feel when part of your life is stuck on ‘just okay’…is God saying, ‘I created you for more than this.’”

The virtue that drives us to seek more is magnanimity, which St. Thomas Aquinas defined as the virtue that disposes a person to undertake great things worthy of honor. It does this while avoiding, on one hand, presumption (attempting what exceeds one’s capacities), and on the other hand, pusillanimity (shrinking from the good one is capable of—a fancier word for “settling”).

“Magnanimity is the virtue of living a life that glorifies God, a life that really shows you at your best, that enables you to participate in relationships that witness to the power of God’s love in our lives,” Dr. Popcak explained. “In a sense, living in a way that glorifies God and asking God every day, Lord, teach me how to respond to this in a way that would really help me glorify you.”

Three Steps for Moving toward Magnanimity

Just as people sometimes confuse settling for less with the virtue of humility, people also sometimes get confused about the pursuit of greatness. Stuart Long, for example, initially sought greatness in the boxing ring, then in Hollywood, and then in a romantic relationship. None of those goals were necessarily bad, but he was pursuing them as an end in themselves, not out of true magnanimity.

Jacob Popcak, a pastoral counselor with CatholicCounselors.com, joined Lisa and Dr. Greg to share a process for discerning what, exactly, we ought to be striving toward as we pursue the greatness God wants for us.

“I don’t want to assume that just because I want a Cadillac automatically means that God desires a Cadillac for me,” he said. “I want to understand what in my desires is really calling me to God.”

Here’s the three-step process he suggests.

1. Write the desire at the top of the page

Put it in plain words: to meet someone you could marry, to find peace in the marriage you already have, to get a particular job.

2. Ask open-ended questions that uncover the real desire

From a calm, prayerful space, ask questions such as:

  • What would it say about me, or what would be true about me, if this desire came to pass?
  • What would change about how other people saw me?
  • What virtues do I imagine I’d have, or would need to have, for this to come to pass?

For example, if you really want a new Cadillac, your investigation of the deeper desire might reveal that you are proud of your success, and you want to enjoy that success and be reminded of the gratitude you have for God’s hand in your life. You might identify the virtues you would need to achieve this goal as hard work, prudence, or patience.

Those revelations might prompt you to dig even deeper. In any case, you are looking for the deeper emotional and psychological underpinning of the desire.

“We’re really sitting with the desire,’ Flores-Popcak said, “and we’re unwrapping it like a present that God wants to give us.”

3. Bring the deeper longing back to God

Once you can name what lies beneath the desire (to feel capable, to be known as someone who didn’t give up, to belong), hand it to God. Ask God: “But how do you want to fulfill the deeper, more vulnerable underpinnings of my desire for more that you’ve placed on my heart?”

Pursuing a Great Life

Later in the show, the Popcaks applied Jacob’s process to a situation that a listener named Joan asked about. Her older sister cut off the whole family sixteen years ago, and Joan still sends letters, emails, and the occasional text in the hope that they might reconnect. Joan asked whether that was wise.

Dr. Popcak affirmed her basic approach, but also named where she might be tempted to settle. “Where we start to settle in these situations,” he said, “is believing that this one person is the only person who can give us healing.”

He invited Joan to ask what a restored relationship would say about her (perhaps that she is a good person, or that she hasn’t given up on her sister) and to bring those needs to God: “If you can identify that and then bring those to God, then he can start to fulfill those deepest longings of your heart, even if your relationship with your sister never improves.”

Rather than waiting on a relationship she can’t control to be her only source of healing, this approach invites her to ask God, “What’s your plan for helping me to heal this part of my heart and to move forward and celebrate the life that you want me to have?”

For more help discerning the path to a great life, reach out to a pastoral counselor at CatholicCounselors.com.

Dr. Popcak’s book The Life God Wants You to Have also offers a faith-based plan for discovering the divine plan when human plans fail.

Worried about What Might Happen Tomorrow? Take These 3 Steps Toward a Calmer, Trusting Response

Quick quiz: Would you rather…

  •       …be interviewed about your life on live national television?
  •       …hold a public meeting with a roomful of your angry constituents?
  •       …compete as an elite athlete for the ultimate prize in your sport?
  •       …represent your company during an IRS audit?

If your answer is a solid “none of the above,” that’s okay: most of us don’t have to worry about performing in such high-stakes situations. Still, the way people who face these situations on a regular basis handle stress and anxiety might teach something to the rest of us.

Enter Rachael Isaac, a pastoral counselor and mental performance coach at CatholicCounselors.com. Isaac directs the faith-based success and performance coaching program, where she works with Catholic athletes, performers, executives, and others who have to be at their best under pressure. She explained a simple three-step process for handling anxiety that she regularly uses with her clients.

When the Future Arrives Early

“Anxiety has a way of making a future problem feel like a present emergency,” Isaac told the Popcaks. “You’re imagining what could go wrong, what the other person might say, what happens if you fail or make a wrong choice.”

The result: We experience the stress of an event over and over again before anything has actually happened, putting our nervous system into overdrive and leaving us exhausted.

The key to breaking that cycle isn’t trying to make the anxiety disappear. Instead, Isaac advises her clients to “recenter” their feelings of anxiety so that instead of living in the stress of hypothetical future outcomes, they can ground themselves in the present, allowing them to respond more effectively.

She outlined three steps for doing that.

Three Steps for Recentering When You’re Stressed

1. Regulate the body first

Anxiety isn’t just a “mind thing”; it’s a body thing, too. When you experience anxiety, your heart rate and breathing speed up, your muscles tense up, and your body floods with stress hormones designed to help you deal with danger.

The problem is, that stress response is geared toward immediate physical danger, not some hypothetical future threat. It prepares your body to either flee, freeze, or fight—responses that don’t work well in most modern contexts.

“So before you try to reason your way out of anxiety, give your body some evidence that you’re safe enough to think,” Isaac said.

Slow your breathing, drop your shoulders, put your feet on the ground, and look around to notice where you actually are right now.

Your goal is to lower the intensity of your body’s stress response enough so that your rational “thinking brain” can come back online, taking control back from the fight-or-flight “reactionary” part of your brain.

2. Name what’s true, and move from “what if” to “even if”

“Anxiety really loves hypothetical situations,” Isaac told the Popcaks: What if I mess up? What if I fail? What if they’re upset with me? Left alone, those questions only escalate.

The most powerful shift we can make here is from “what if” to “even if,” Isaac said: Even if I mess up, I can take a deep breath and get back on track. Even if they’re upset with me, I can remain calm and present and work through the situation. Even if I fail, “I have X, Y, and Z ways to respond.”

Try this the next time your mind starts spinning. Write down your top “what ifs,” then finish each one with an “even if.” Those sentences should sound different from the catastrophic “what if” versions, giving the thinking part of your brain something solid to go on.

3. Identify what’s yours to do

Next, ask what you can actually do right now. You might prepare, pray, or rest, for instance.

Or you may conclude there is nothing more to do. That can be a useful insight, too, since anxiety often convinces us that worry is a useful form of preparation.

“It feels productive because our brain is working so hard,” Isaac explained. “But repeatedly imagining that worst case scenario doesn’t actually make us more prepared.”

Grace for the Moment You’re In

Jesus taught his disciples to let each day’s worries be enough for that day (Matthew 6:34). Instead of worrying about what might happen tomorrow, he told them to trust in God’s providential care.

“Trust doesn’t mean convincing ourselves that everything is going to turn out exactly the way that we want,” Isaac explained. “It means recognizing I’m responsible for my response; I’m not responsible for controlling the entire outcome. So I can prepare, I can discern, I can show up, I can make that next healthy choice.”

But there comes a point where we have to let go of what is beyond our control. Often, we want God to assure us that all of our doomsday scenarios are under control.

“But grace meets us in the moment when we actually need it,” she said. “Calm doesn’t always mean that the nerves disappear. Calm sometimes simply means, even if I’m feeling nervous, I can take that next faithful, healthy step and know that God is walking with me.”

For more help overcoming anxiety, check out Dr. Greg Popcak’s book Unworried: A Life Without Anxiety. And for one-on-one support, or to learn more about faith-based performance coaching, reach out to a pastoral counselor at CatholicCounselors.com.

Big Decision? Don’t Wait for God to Text the Answer; Try These Questions Instead

Rindy had prayed a nine-day novena to St. Thérèse. She had prayed the rosary nightly. She had asked God, plainly and repeatedly, to help her decide whether to go back to her job after her maternity leave or stay at home with her children.

Despite all that prayer, she was still unclear about what to do when she called into the More2Life radio show on the EWTN radio network.

“I’m not getting that text message (from God),” she told hosts Dr. Greg Popcak and Lisa Popcak. “I’m not getting that clear answer.”

Like Rindy, many people want to do the right thing, the thing God is calling them to do, but as much as they ask for clear direction, they are still left wondering which road to take.

While the Popcaks were not able to point Rindy in one direction or another, they did share some advice that could help her, and others in her position, move forward with a big decision more confidently.

Don’t Wait for Angels and a Light from Heaven

Most of us feel it would be great if God were super clear about what direction we ought to take, Lisa Popcak acknowledged. “We just want to hear the angels singing, and God’s light shining upon (the correct) decision,” she said.

But as the spiritual master St. Ignatius of Loyola pointed out, God doesn’t tend to send us angels (or text messages) unless there is no other way for us to discern his will. Yes, St. Paul got blinded by a light from heaven, but he was utterly convinced that he was serving God by persecuting the early Church. It took a dramatic intervention to point him in the right direction.

In most cases, though, God “tends to incline our hearts toward (the right path) as we sit and reflect on (our options),” Dr. Popcak said. As generations of holy men and women have learned, God wants his people to grow closer to him, and that requires the work of discernment.

But this can lead to another question: How do we know that it is God who is inclining our hearts in one direction or another? What if we’re just following our own selfish desires?

A Compass for Discernment

Drawing on St. John Paul II’s Theology of the Body, the Popcaks offer a simple way to interrogate the inclinations of our heart. Ask: “Is this inner prompting pointing me toward meaningfulness, intimacy, and virtue?”

If it is, then there is a good chance that prompting is from the Holy Spirit. If, on the other hand, it points you toward powerlessness, isolation, or self-pity and self-indulgence, then it likely does not come from God.

Why test any inner prompting against these three criteria? Meaningfulness is what lets you use your gifts to bless someone else. Intimacy is all about building deeper, healthier relationships. And virtue helps you become the person God made you to be. Together, these three conditions act like a compass, pointing you toward the abundant, fulfilling life God wants you to have.

“The next time you’re standing at a fork in the road asking, ‘Which way, Lord?’” Dr. Popcak said, “stop hunting for the secret answer. Check your compass: Ask which road makes you more of a gift, brings you closer to the people in your life and gives you healthier relationships with and enables you to become the stronger, healthier, more virtuous person God’s calling you to be.”

Three Ways to Put the Compass to Work

Besides this three-question compass, the Popcaks offer some additional advice for people discerning big decisions.

  1. Give God all the options, not just two. “Instead of just saying to God, ‘Okay, Lord, do you want me to do this or that,’ say, ‘Okay, Lord, help me to see all the possibilities,’” Dr. Popcak suggested. Rindy, for instance, had more than two possibilities (staying home or going to work full time) open to her. Be open to all the possibilities, and let God point out ones you might not have considered.
  2. Ask, ‘Is it possible,’ not ‘Is it perfect?’ As she was explaining her thinking to the Popcaks, Rindy offered a long list of considerations: How will we handle tight finances without the extra income? How will being home all day affect my mental health? These are valid considerations, but it’s important to distinguish which of them are serious enough to take an option off the table entirely, and which are logistical questions that can be figured out later. The truth is, whatever path you take is going to have its challenges (and its joys)—that’s just life. And it’s also true that, whatever path you take, God will be right there with you, helping you to manage those challenges.
  3. Bring the questions back to prayer more than once. The three-question compass is not a one-and-done silver bullet. Rather, plan on sitting with the questions across several days of prayer. Collect facts about each of your choices, too; in Rindy’s case, this might mean talking to her employer and her spouse, and taking a close look at the family finances. Both strategies will help you to have more certainty about the direction you should take.

Don’t Wait for Absolute Certainty

Once you have tested your options against the three “compass questions” over several days, don’t wait for 100% certainty—because it’s not likely to show up. Instead, trust that as long as you have been discerning in good faith, God will have your back.

Dr. Popcak said he will often entrust his decision to God with a prayer: “Okay, Lord, based on the fact that this is possible, and it seems to lead to greater meaningfulness, intimacy, and virtue, this is what I’m going to do. But if that’s not what you want me to do, please hit me upside the head and let me know.”

As long as you’re generally moving toward meaningfulness, intimacy, and virtue, a wrong turn isn’t fatal; God will help you adjust your course along the way.

If you’re wrestling with a decision and could use help applying this discernment framework to your own life, the pastoral counselors at CatholicCounselors.com are ready to walk with you. Dr. Popcak’s book, The Life God Wants You to Have: Discovering the Divine Plan When Human Plans Fail, goes deeper into this exact process for anyone facing a fork in the road.